Crime and Mystery Fans, Visit The Mysterious Bookshop In NYC

The world-famous Mysterious Bookshop, located in Manhattan’s Tribeca neighborhood, is the oldest and largest mystery specialist bookstore in America. Otto Penzler founded this beloved bookstore in 1979, and it is a must-see for any New Yorker or visitor looking for authentic, old-school New York charm, long before so many of its unique shops were taken over by big box stores or name-brand coffee shops.

Here are all the relevant details about the renowned Mysterious Bookshop, a one-of-a-kind establishment where readers are bound to become engrossed in a mystery or two.

A Mystery for the Ages

Otto Penzler founded it in 1979, determined to transform the genre of crime fiction, which, while always popular, did not always command the literary world’s appreciation. Penzler, the founder of The Mysterious Press, is the editor of numerous mystery anthologies that have garnered international attention. His office, which is located inside the bookstore, is cordoned off by yellow police tape that warns customers to “Crime Scene Do Not Cross.”

Entering The Mysterious Bookshop is frequently awe-inspiring. Every available space is taken up by mysteries, detective yarns, criminal fiction, and murderous tales, from the floor to the incredibly high ceilings where books can only be reached by a ladder, from the shelves, tables, and stands—any available space. Check out one of the sections called Bibliomysteries, a term Penzler coined to refer to mysteries involving other mystery books, for those who are truly devoted to the genre. The entire bookshop is a shrine to a beloved genre that seeks to frighten, surprise, and confound its readers.

Sherlock Holmes Fans Should Visit Mysterious Bookshop

What would a mystery shop be without the ultimate detective himself? And Mysterious Bookshop not only has a good selection of Sherlock Holmes books, but it also has the world’s largest collection. The shop sells original first editions and even hosts an open house on Sherlock’s birthday every year. Could visitors get lost in the famous detective’s section? Without a doubt! Or, more precisely, “Elementary, my dear Watson…”

With these crime clubs, you’re innocent until proven guilty

The Mysterious Bookshop’s many crime clubs and literature clubs are among its most endearing features. From its beginnings as a bookstore, Penzler offered readers the opportunity to join one of their subscription clubs, which allowed book lovers to receive signed first editions from popular mystery authors. Every month, club members receive a signed first edition.

Plan your trip to Manhattan

Found something amazing? Spread the wonder and share it with your friends! 🥰